Skip to content
Wednesday, November 18, 2026
Northern Nurture

Why Caicedo Received a Red Card Whereas Bentancur Avoided One: An Analysis of Seeming Lack of Uniformity.

A Chelsea side down to ten men The Blues secure Arsenal to a draw in fiery London derby.

Chelsea manager Maresca was feeling aggrieved. Not because of the dismissal of his midfielder against Arsenal, but over what he viewed as a notable absence of consistency from the match referees.

It's easy to understand his point. In a previous fixture, Spurs player Bentancur was shown a yellow card for a foul on Reece James, a decision the video review system upheld. Yet, when Caicedo was cautioned for a seemingly similar tackle on the Arsenal player, the VAR intervened to recommend a red card.

"It's a red card, however, why was Bentancur's against Reece James not a dismissal? We, as coaches, we struggle to understand why they judge in a dissimilar manner," the manager questioned.

So, What Was the Distinction?

Ultimately, rulings are often influenced upon the specific official on VAR duty—which makes absolute uniformity very difficult.

No two fouls is unique, and there were nuanced distinctions between the pair of tackles. The Tottenham player was largely stepping in, whereas Caicedo left the ground slightly and his impact was a bit more elevated.

There was also a pronounced buckle of Merino's ankle, which is a video referee watches for to signal undue severity, and his boot was shifted on the turf.

In Bentancur's case, the Premier League's Key Match Incidents (KMI) Panel backed the yellow card for Bentancur by a vote of 4-1, and unanimously backed no VAR intervention "due to the reasoning that the tackle was low, marginally tardy and reckless".

This same panel will undoubtedly back the call to dismiss the Chelsea midfielder, but it may not be long before another tackle of this nature is judged just a yellow card.

Was the Video Official Instruct the Referee to Show a Caution?

Moises Caicedo will be banned for three matches following his dismissal against Arsenal.

The situation appeared somewhat perplexing at first. Was referee Taylor being told to caution the player so the incident could be checked?

In reality, there's a much more straightforward reason.

Taylor allowed play to continue for Arsenal as the loose ball was with Eberechi Eze. When it went out for a throw-in, the official returned to book the offender, who was down injured. Officials are told to delay until an player at fault is back on their feet before displaying a disciplinary sanction.

So, the delay was not because the video review process; it was because Caicedo was being treated.

Video assistant referee John Brooks can reach the determination that there was sufficient severity for a dismissal, but he has to wait for Taylor to indicate his initial decision. The moment he showed a caution, the VAR immediately sent him to the review screen because the check had been completed during the treatment.

England Rejects Sending-Off VAR Recommendation

Also on Sunday, for only the second time in the top flight, a match official rejected a red card review at the on-field review screen.

Darren England hadn't given a free-kick against the player, so in contrast to the Arsenal incident, the resumption of play was a set piece to Aston Villa. The video assistant, James Bell, believed that the manner Arias launched himself with studs showing endangered the opponent's safety.

However, the challenger was in the air and made a reckless attempt, making contact with the upper part of Kamara's boot. It did not have the kind of force typically required for a straight red, even if it was a poor challenge.

Was There a Case For The Blues' Goal to Be Disallowed for Offside?

The VAR decided that Enzo Fernandez did not interfere on the defenders when Chalobah headed in the opening goal for the home side.

Once again, and another set of subjective rulings on player positioning.

A possible offside on the Blues' opener appears to have gone under the radar.

The Chelsea captain floated a set-piece in from the left flank, and Chalobah flicked a header into the back of the net.

However, there existed a problem. Enzo Fernandez was stood in an illegal position and was in close proximity to defenders Piero Hincapie and Cristhian Mosquera.

Was the midfielder affect the actions of the defenders? Had the Chelsea player not been there, would there have been a better chance of stopping the header?

He made no attempt to make contact with the ball, and while he was not directly engaging with one defender, he had his arm on the other's shoulder.

One could argue a very strong case for offside, so it returns us to a question of consistency once again.

Should Hincapie Deserve Red for an Use of the Elbow?

Piero Hincapie started for the Gunners with their first-choice centre-backs ruled out through injury.

The incident occurred shortly after the Caicedo sending-off. The Arsenal defender went up for a ball with the Chelsea player, and the Chelsea defender sustained contact through contact by the arm on his head.

"I questioned the referee, he told me that it was not an elbow offence," the Chelsea manager explained. "That was what they said. He had a black eye, with an ice pack at half-time. But they decide in a different way."

Referees should not make judgements based on a potential injury, though it occurs sometimes. A player can receive a cut or a contusion from many kinds of challenges, so it would not be a sound basis.

As with serious foul play, referees have a set of criteria they consider for a potential elbow offence.

  • Did it involve an abnormal movement of challenging for a aerial ball?
  • Was there a clenched fist, suggesting malicious intent?
  • Did the arm thrown or raised to generate power?

None of these were present, so a yellow card was considered appropriate.

By

Robert Richardson

A forward-thinking strategist with a passion for technology and sustainable business practices, sharing insights to inspire change.

Northern Nurture

Type to search articles.